Growing Slowly: How Maura Duggan Has Scaled Fancypants Baking Co. Over Two Decades

LISTEN ON: APPLE | SPOTIFY

When Maura Duggan started Fancypants Baking Co. two decades ago, it was just her, baking decorative cookies in her kitchen in Massachusetts. Twenty years later, Maura’s family has grown and changed… and so has her business.

In this episode, Maura is sharing how her company slowly grew into a national brand, what she’s learned in every step of expanding her business, and how she eventually decided that it was time to move to premium CPG cookies over decorated baked goods.

She also opens up on her decision not to take on as little debt as possible, how she thought about scaling carefully, and what she thinks has helped her company grow to its current reach.

Maura is super open and honest, and you’re going to get so many great insights. Let’s jump in!

Subscribe to the Food Means Business Podcast with Hudson Kitchen founder Djenaba Johnson-Jones to hear the personal stories and “secret ingredients” of abandoning your day job and starting a CPG food business.

In this episode, you’ll learn...

  • [00:50] Maura’s original plan to be a neuroscientist and how that shifted into baking

  • [06:02] How Maura thought about finances when transitioning into a baking career

  • [10:59] The challenges Maura navigated while scaling her business, including transitioning to a commercial kitchen

  • [22:10] How Maura’s experiences helped her hire the right advisors when the time came

  • [27:06] How Maura thinks about networking and the ways it’s helped her grow

If you’re a CPG entrepreneur looking for a relatable and inspiring story from a fellow business owner in the trenches, be sure to tune into this episode:

To get more Food Business Bites right in your inbox, sign up for our newsletter at thehudsonkitchen.com.


About Maura Duggan
Fancypants is a proudly women-owned brand crafting delicious crispy cookies with an elevated twist, using high-quality ingredients. Founded by Maura Duggan in 2004, Fancypants originally started as a decorative cookie company in Walpole, Massachusetts selling to grocery store bakeries - most notably, Whole Foods Market. Maura evolved the company with her husband and COO Justin Housman into a premium CPG cookie brand in December 2023, inspired by the homemade cookies she made with her grandmother after school. 

One of the most impressive accomplishments about Fancypants is that they’ve been operating their own manufacturing facility since within the first three months of launching out of their tiny Boston apartment kitchen, so that Maura and Justin could oversee their own production line to ensure quality control and scale the business. No stranger to taking risks, Maura started her early career in neuropsychology education after earning a Masters from Harvard University. She pursued her passion for baking to become an entrepreneur within the multi-billion dollar cookie category. Maura has primarily self-funded the business and taken on private investors in the last couple of years, with plans to fundraise as the company grows. 

As one of the first upcycled cookies, Fancypants is dedicated to building a high-quality brand that is tackling sustainability and keeping the environment top of mind. Fancypants is Upcycled Certified as they bake with upcycled oat flour made from dried and milled oat pulp left after making oat milk. Fancypants combines the oat flour with King Arthur Baking Company’s flour to make its proprietary flour blend along with real butter, sugar, and eggs — no artificial ingredients in its cookies. With a commitment to being zero-waste, Fancypants turns any cookies that get broken during the process of its production cycle into renewable energy via its partnership with Farm Powered. This food waste is converted into carbon-negative renewable natural gas to cleanly power farms in Massachusetts. 


In the first six months of launching the CPG line, Fancypants is in over 1,500 retailers including Central Market, Gelson’s, and Mother’s Market (store locator here) at a suggested retail price of $5.99 per bag. Fancypants flavors are a range of classic, approachable, and innovative with a special fancy twist, with its six current flavors including Birthday Cake, Chocolate Chip, Mint Chocolate, Oatmeal Raisin, S’Mores and Salted Caramel.


Connect with Maura Duggan:

Visit the Fancypants Baking Co.website

Follow Fancypants Baking Co. on Instagram

Follow Fancypants Baking Co. on Facebook

Connect with Maura Duggan on LinkedIn


Stay Connected with Djenaba Johnson-Jones:

Visit Hudson Kitchen

Follow Djenaba on Instagram

Connect with Djenaba on LinkedIn

Previous
Previous

Building Brooklyn Delhi on Her Own Terms with Chitra Agrawal

Next
Next

The Power of Persistence: How Bruno LeGreco Keeps The Biscotti Company Growing